The Black experience at work: findings from the D&I Strategy Report

27 Nov 21 | Blog

How do you drive Diversity & Inclusion in the workplace? We’ve partnered with Robert Walters, CV Library, Pearn Kandola, The Kaleidoscope Group, and the Inclusive Group to survey 7,500 UK and Irish professionals – all to understand issues, trends, and best practice around D&I.

From the report: some key takeaways around ethnicity and inclusion

BAME as a catch-all is not a helpful term

BAME stands for Black, Asian and Minority Ethnic.  As a term, it can be more problematic than beneficial as it seems to cement the white supremacist idea of the white majority versus all other identities. Along with this idea is the inferred intention that all other identities should integrate into the white majority’s cultural norms within societies and organisations, contrary to many ideas of what true inclusion and belonging should look like.

The term can also disguise the discrimination specific to certain ethnic groups, and doesn’t allow for their very different experiences. Our data served to highlight this point, with large disparities reported between the experiences of the different ethnic groups we identified; African & Caribbean, Arab, Bangladeshi, Chinese, other Asian, Indian and Pakistani.

Our data suggests that the ethnicities that are held back the most in their careers are: Arab, Bangladeshi, Pakistani and African and Caribbean.  These groups appear to report more negative workplace experiences that their Chinese, Indian, other Asian and White colleagues.  That is not to say that Chinese, Indian and other Asian employees do not experience bias in the workplace but, again, the form may be quite different than for Black Caribbean employees.

Barriers to progression for Black professionals

The majority of Black professionals (62%) state that having a lack of opportunities made available to them is their biggest career challenge, almost 10% higher than for white professionals.  Additionally, and perhaps not surprisingly, half of black professionals (49%) state that a lack of diversity in management or senior positions also presents a significant challenge for them, as opposed to only 22% of white professionals.

This lack of representation presents a significant barrier in and of itself:, without Black people in positions of power, and with decision-making authority for hiring and promotion decisions, the lack of diversity becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy.  More than a third (36%) of Black professionals state that they are impacted by the lack of diversity in their industry, significantly more than their white counterparts (22%).

Unsuccessful pay negotiations for Black professionals

Black professionals were the least satisfied with their pay of all ethnicities surveyed.  Despite there being little difference between the proportion of Black and white professionals that have attempted to negotiate their salary in their career, there is a significant difference in the level of success of those negotiations.

42% of Black professionals (44% of Black Africans and 39% of Black Caribbeans), who attempted a salary negotiation, did not receive any increase at all – this was around double than for white professionals at just 21%.  What’ is more, white professionals were the most likely of any ethnicity to be successful in negotiating their salaries, with 35% receiving 75%-100% of the figure that they asked for – where, only 20% if black professionals received the same increase.  Even more tellingly, Black caribbeans are the most likely to think that their employer would not give them a pay rise (37%).

Get the report


Unfortunately, we know that racism is still widely prevalent in our talent systems -, all the way from our school systems, to recruitment, performance management and, as our data has shown in promotions, salary negotiations and management and leadership representation.

First of all, it’s important to call it what it is: systemic racism. That is, racism that exists within our systems.  If we don’t first acknowledge it as such, we will not be able to fix the underlying problem at the level of the system.  We’ll just continue to implement interventions such as ‘unconscious bias training’ with little to no positive impact.

In order to tackle problems inherent to the systems in which we operate, we suggest auditing your talent systems to understand what are the barriers to diversity, equity and inclusion.  For a deeper understanding, please see a previous article we wrote on this topic.

Measuring inclusion is key to creating a diverse workforce

Of course, improving diversity on its own will not solve the problem.  Organisations must simultaneously be looking to create cultures of inclusivity.  At Qlearsite, we have developed an inclusion framework which shows 4 subdimensions of inclusion. Once you think about inclusion in this sort of detail, you can start to identify ways to improve equality at work, as well as what you can celebrate within your company.

The framework is part of our wider Diversity & Inclusion survey and analysis, but these 4 definitions should add helpful context:

  • Safety and Access: the idea that everyone has equal access to the facilities and resources within an organisation and feels safe at work
  • Acceptance:  the idea that everyone can be their authentic selves and that rewards that are not influenced by identity
  • Trust and fairness: Everyone has confidence that processes and procedures can be trusted and that leaders or those in authority will act appropriately, without bias
  • Belonging: Everyone feels valued in the workplace, that all identities are celebrated and their organisation embraces differences
Someone with no money

UK cost-of-living crisis: what it means for your business

A 9% rise in inflation has triggered a cost-of-living crisis. And like any other crisis, that’s going to have an impact on your business.

Missing staff

The UK labour shortage: what you need to know

Have you noticed it? The lack of response to your job advertisements, the overstretched teams? For...

HR’s guide to the EU Pay Transparency Directive

All too often, pay isn’t fair. From different wages for the same job, to a culture of silence...

How will the general election impact the job market?

Sometimes, we’re so focused on what’s happening in our organisation, we forget to consider what’s...
Overworked person

HR department of one? Here’s how to make a difference

It’s lonely to be in a one-person department. It’s even worse to be a one-person Human Resources...
Time out

5 things that HR doesn’t have time for

There’s only so many hours in a day. And there’s even fewer working hours… in theory. But for a...
What does HR do for employees really?

Seriously, what does HR do for employees?

“Oops, watch out - HR might be listening” “Don’t tell HR I said that!” “I’m not sure HR would be...
Window with money behind

Pay transparency is business critical: here’s why

‘Competitive’. What does the word mean? What is it hiding? Do people writing job advertisements...
Not talking about money

3 reasons bosses avoid ‘pay chats’ (and how benchmarks help)

No-one actually enjoys talking about money, do they? Whether you’re the employee or their manager,...

Salary benchmarking by Qlearsite Pro

Whatever kind of people leader you are - HR professional, CEO, team lead, line manager - then...

Get a live demo
of the platform 

Anne Therese Bogen, Head of HR, Thommessen

"Qlearsite’s platform is a really helpful tool to push through OKRs – it’s easier when you have statistics and concrete evidence to back up initiatives."